Tony's Pizza And Pasta Information

If you find yourself in the Freehold, NY area and craving a satisfying meal, Tony's Pizza And Pasta is a spot you won’t want to miss. Located at 9495 NY-32, this cozy diner offers a warm and inviting atmosphere that’s perfect for a casual lunch or dinner with friends and family. It’s the kind of place where you can always count on a hearty, comforting meal without the hassle of a long wait or pretentious vibes.

The menu at Tony's is a delightful mix of classic Italian-American favorites, with something for everyone. Of course, pizza is the star of the show here, and it’s easy to see why. Whether you’re into a classic Margherita or something a bit more adventurous like their BBQ Chicken Pizza, the crust is always perfectly crispy, and the toppings are generous. But it’s not just the pizza that shines-Tony’s Pasta dishes are just as impressive. The spaghetti with marinara sauce is simple but executed to perfection, with a rich, flavorful sauce that sticks just right to the noodles. If you’re feeling like a heavier bite, the lasagna is a crowd favorite, packed with layers of cheese, meat, and perfectly seasoned sauce.

The restaurant also does a great job offering other Italian classics like chicken parmigiana and meatball subs, which are always served hot and fresh. If you’re looking for variety, there are also a few salads and appetizers on the menu, including the crunchy fried calamari, which is always a hit. The portions are more than generous, making it an excellent place to get great value for your money.

Service at Tony’s is casual but friendly, with the waitstaff always ready to offer suggestions if you can’t decide what to order. It’s clear that this place is loved by locals, with regulars often spotted chatting with the staff like old friends. The ambiance feels homey, with its laid-back diner vibe and unpretentious décor. You won’t find any fancy touches here, but that’s part of the charm. It’s the kind of place you can drop into on a whim, grab a great meal, and feel completely comfortable.

Tony’s is also known for being reliable when it comes to takeout and delivery, making it a great option when you’re craving comfort food without leaving the house. Whether you’re dining in or enjoying your meal at home, the quality remains consistently high.

Located just outside of the bustling center of Freehold, NY, Tony’s Pizza And Pasta is a perfect little gem for anyone who loves a well-made pizza or classic Italian dish. With its friendly service, satisfying menu, and comfortable atmosphere, it’s a spot that feels just like home.

Business Info

What People's Say About Place

I’ve lived in the area for 3 years and have passed by here probably 100 times… I am sad and embarrassed that it took me this long to stop. The pizza was delicious and cooked to perfection for me. The crust is lite, airy and has an amazing crunch but yet wasn’t stiff. Flavors were great and fresh. The smoked Gouda and bacon Mac and cheese bits were top notch and though I haven’t ate the peanut butter brownie yet, I have a feeling it’s going to be killer! The staff is super friendly as well, the guy behind the counter made me feel like an old friend despite it being my first time in! Finally a pizza place I like in the area!

Loved our Grandma Pie and Meatball Calzone...giant portions!

Who would’ve thought you could find top-tier, delicious pizza tucked away in the tiny hamlet of Freehold, NY? Seriously, blink and you’ll miss the town — but trust me, you won’t miss Tony’s once you’ve been. Where do I even begin? I ordered a large pizza with sausage and pepperoni. Absolute perfection. The crust had just the right crunch, the sausage had that savory kick, and the pepperoni had a glorious sizzle. The sauce? Chef’s kiss. No syrupy sweetness here — just the pure, honest flavor of tomatoes doing what tomatoes were born to do. But wait, there’s more. The Chicken Parmigiana Dinner — and yes, it’s a DINNER, not some sad little plate — came with a fresh, crisp garden salad, two generous pieces of tender chicken covered in golden, bubbly mozzarella, and a side of pasta with marinara. Full transparency: the pasta was just a touch overcooked. But listen, I ordered takeout — pasta steaming itself into overtime in a container is just a sign that they’re sending you home with a piping hot meal, not a cold afterthought. Now, let’s talk about the focaccia. Perfectly crispy edges, soft, pillowy center, and seasoned just right. If focaccia could win awards, this one would have a trophy case. My only suggestion: offer a side of marinara for dipping! (I would’ve happily paid extra — and trust me, you want every excuse to eat more of that marinara.) Bottom line: If you’re within 50 miles of Freehold and you’re NOT stopping by Tony’s… rethink your life choices. Big flavor. Small town. Endless cravings. Highly, highly recommend! “Food that feeds the soul, beauty that speaks volumes, and travel that tells a story always through the eyes of Italy Loves India.” — Alyson Savino

Even after all of the Pizza I’ve tried in NYC, this blows everything else out of the water! So good every time and the staff is incredible

My favorite little pizza place. I’ve been going for years. Everyone there is always friendly and food is great. Highly recommended. We normally get a couple pizzas and some buffalo chicken tenders.

Awesome pizza spot in freehold, best pizza and wings around, especially the buffalo chicken

Tony's Pizza And Pasta